Here are your estimates — gathered, compared, and the fine print decoded.
Every quote we collected for one property, lined up apples to apples — fine print decoded and the reviews read for real patterns, so the cheapest sticker (or the shiniest star rating) does not fool you. (Companies below are fictional — this is a sample of the real report.)
We work for you — not the contractors. We don’t get paid by them, we don’t mark up their quotes, and we don’t take commissions. The $19.99 you pay is the only money we make — so the only side we’re on is yours.
Our recommendation — this is who we’d choose
Sunshine Overhead Doors — $1,850
Deepest clean record here (312 reviews). Only recurring note is minor scheduling slips — pin a firm date and you are golden. Best balance of price, warranty, and reputation.
Want premium? Premier Door & Gate or Sunset Door & Opener cost more but include the longest warranties and zero add-ons. We’d steer you clear of Reliable Door Pros, Budget Garage Kings, ABC Doors LLC — see why below.
You always make the final call — we just make it obvious.
Your request
2-car garage door replacement
Naples, FL 34102 · Insulated steel door + new opener; haul away the old one.
Our legwork
19 contacted · 11 quotes
We reached 19 local pros and gathered 11 real estimates (up to 20 — stopped when you had plenty).
| Contractor | True cost | Availability | Warranty | Reviews | Our read |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Sunshine Overhead Doors ✓ Our pickDoor, opener, haul-away included View the contract | $1,850 | ~2 weeks | 5-yr parts | 4.6 312 reviews | Clean |
Premier Door & Gate PremiumDoor, smart opener, permit, haul-away — all in View the contract | $2,300 | ~1 week | 10-yr door + opener | 4.9 41 reviews | Clean |
Sunset Door & Opener PremiumDoor, opener, haul-away, permit View the contract | $2,050 | ~1–2 weeks | 7-yr | 4.8 129 reviews | Clean |
Bright Garage Doors Door, opener, haul-away View the contract | $1,890 | ~2 weeks | 4-yr | 4.7 203 reviews | Clean |
Naples Garage Door Co. Door, opener, haul-away View the contract | $1,950 | ~2 weeks | 5-yr parts | 4.5 264 reviews | Clean |
Paradise Garage Solutions Door, opener, haul-away View the contract | $1,770 sticker $1,650 | ~2–3 weeks | 3-yr | 4.4 188 reviews | Watch the add-ons |
Coastline Overhead Door, opener (haul-away +$120) View the contract | $1,720 | ~3 weeks | 2-yr | 4.3 151 reviews | Watch the add-ons |
Gulf Coast Garage Pros Door + opener only View the contract | $1,640 sticker $1,490 | ~3–4 weeks | 1-yr | 4.1 96 reviews | Watch the add-ons |
Reliable Door Pros SkipDoor, opener View the contract | $1,580 | ~3 weeks | 1-yr | 3.9 78 reviews | Watch the add-ons |
Budget Garage Kings SkipDoor, opener (basic) View the contract | $1,350 | ~4 weeks | Not stated | 3.6 44 reviews | Not a real quote |
ABC Doors LLC SkipUnclear — phone estimate only View the contract | TBD sticker $1,295 | Call to schedule | Not stated | 4.7 23 reviews | Not a real quote |
How we read the reviews
A star average lies. We read the reviews and pull out the patterns — what people praise again and again, and the complaints that keep coming up. We discount the outliers (one “I drove there and it was closed” 1-star does not define a contractor with 300 happy customers), but when the same problem repeats, that is a habit — and we flag it. Like a restaurant where everyone says the food is bad: if enough people say it, it is probably true. You get the honest picture, not the marketing number.
The full read on each contractor
The fine print decoded, plus what the reviews really say once the outliers are stripped out.
Fine print: All-in at $1,850 with haul-away included. The 5-yr warranty covers parts; labor is covered 1 year. No surprise add-ons.
Reviewers praise
- • Quality doors that last
- • Friendly, respectful crews
- • Good warranty follow-up
Watch for
- • A few mention scheduling can slip a couple days
Our read: Deepest clean record here (312 reviews). Only recurring note is minor scheduling slips — pin a firm date and you are golden. Best balance of price, warranty, and reputation.
Fine print: Truly all-in: price is firm, permit and haul-away included, longest warranty of the bunch, smart opener included. Priciest sticker, nothing added later.
Reviewers praise
- • Spotless, fast installs
- • Shows up exactly on time
- • No surprise charges
Watch for
- • Several say it is the priciest in town
Our read: Small but glowing record; the only repeated word is "expensive." If you want the longest warranty, the smart opener, and zero hassle, this is the premium choice.
Fine print: Everything included, 7-yr warranty. Slightly above mid-pack on price but no extras tacked on later.
Reviewers praise
- • Excellent communication
- • Clean, on-time installs
- • Great warranty service
Watch for
- • A couple wished they had more color options
Our read: Excellent 4.8 across 129 reviews with no real pattern of problems. A strong premium alternative to Premier at $250 less.
Fine print: Mid-pack price, haul-away included, 4-yr warranty. Quote is itemized and clear.
Reviewers praise
- • Best communication of the bunch
- • Tidy work
- • Honest pricing
Watch for
- • A few note booking can be a week or two out
Our read: Very solid 4.7 over 203 reviews. No troubling patterns — communication is the standout. A safe pick a notch below Sunshine on warranty.
Fine print: A bit above mid-price; 5-yr parts warranty, haul-away included. Long-established local shop.
Reviewers praise
- • Established, trusted name
- • Knowledgeable techs
Watch for
- • Some say slightly pricey for what you get
- • A few slow callback mentions
Our read: Reliable, well-reviewed (4.5 / 264). Nothing alarming — just priced a touch high vs. Sunshine for similar coverage.
Fine print: Sticker is $1,650, but the permit fee (~$120) is NOT included — true cost ≈ $1,770. Quote only valid 14 days.
Reviewers praise
- • Tidy, careful work
- • Good communication up front
Watch for
- • Recurring: jobs finish 1–2 weeks past the promised date
- • A few hit with the permit fee they did not expect
Our read: "Runs late" shows up again and again across 188 reviews — a habit, not an outlier, so we flag it. Fine work if you get the completion date in writing.
Fine print: Haul-away is a $120 add-on. Short 2-yr warranty. Quote is firm otherwise.
Reviewers praise
- • Good price
- • Polite crews
Watch for
- • A recurring handful needed a follow-up visit to fix the install
- • Short warranty noted often
Our read: Decent value, but the "needed a redo" complaint repeats enough to watch, and the 2-yr warranty is the shortest of the good options.
Fine print: Cheapest real quote on paper, but haul-away is +$150 (true cost ≈ $1,640), the 50% deposit is non-refundable, and the insulated-panel upgrade you asked for is quoted separately. Shortest warranty.
Reviewers praise
- • Lowest bids around
- • Quick to send a quote
Watch for
- • Repeated add-on charges after the quote
- • Several deposit/refund headaches
- • A few rushed installs needing a re-visit
Our read: The low price comes with a repeating pattern: add-ons after the quote and deposit disputes. We discounted one off-topic rant, but those complaints recur too often to ignore — lock the full price first.
Fine print: Low price, but haul-away not included and warranty is only 1 year.
Reviewers praise
- • Inexpensive
- • Gets the door working
Watch for
- • Recurring: very hard to reach after the install
- • Warranty claims go unanswered, several say
Our read: Sub-4.0 with a clear pattern of going quiet after they have your money. The price is tempting but the after-service complaints repeat — we would not.
Fine print: Lowest "firm" price, but no warranty stated and the panel grade is the builder-basic tier, not what you asked for.
Reviewers praise
- • Cheap
Watch for
- • Repeated no-shows on the install date
- • Heavy upsell pressure once on-site
- • A few report the cheap panel dented fast
Our read: A real pattern of no-shows and on-site upselling, plus a low 3.6. The sticker is the cheapest, but this is exactly the kind of "deal" that costs you later. Avoid.
Fine print: Lowest number, but it is a phone estimate, NOT a firm quote — the real price is set after an on-site visit, and there is an $89 trip charge if you do not book. No warranty stated.
Reviewers praise
- • A couple of very positive (but generic) reviews
Watch for
- • One detailed complaint about the surprise trip charge
Our read: A 4.7 that rests on just 23 thin, generic reviews is not real signal. Combined with the phone-only "estimate" and trip charge, there is too little to trust. Treat the $1,295 as a teaser.
Maria’s bottom line
Your estimate concierge
That “$1,295” from ABC isn’t a real quote — it jumps after an on-site visit and carries a trip charge. Gulf Coast looks cheapest at $1,490 but lands near $1,640 once haul-away and the panel upgrade are added, with the shortest warranty. For best value, Sunshine ($1,850, haul-away included, 5-yr parts) edges out Paradise. If you want zero hassle and the longest warranty, Premier is genuinely all-in at $2,300. You decide — we just make the choice obvious.
Get this for your property — $19.99.
Tell us the property, the job, and your name & phone. We gather up to 20 estimates, decode the fine print, read every contractor’s reviews for the real patterns, and send you a report just like this one. We work for you, not the contractors.
Get my 20 estimates — $19.99Backed by our satisfaction guarantee · Your info is never sold — we only share what a contractor needs to quote your job.
Sample for illustration. Company names, prices, and terms are fictional examples of the report format — your real report shows the actual contractors and quotes we gather for your property.